Taking the full measure of life

Learning to make salads I love

February 13th, 2008 · 18 Comments

If you're new here and want to understand the title and purpose of my blog, you can read my first post by clicking here. You may also want to subscribe to my RSS feed so that you don't miss further posts of interest to you. Thanks for visiting, and I hope you'll stop by often!

I can’t say I grew up hating salads, because I thought I loved them. Unfortunately, once I was an adult, I realized that I didn’t actually love my childhood salads; I loved drenching lettuce in really high-fat, high-calorie toppings and dressings and then eating those foods. A typical tasty salad of my childhood would have been iceberg lettuce topped with pre-shredded cheddar, bacon bits (or Bacos), chopped onion, chopped tomato, fried chicken, and 3 or 4 tablespoons of Kraft ranch dressing. That’s the kind of salad where you might actually be better off eating a burger. Every time I actually write out something like that it hits me that the fact that I wasn’t an enormous kid is a testament to the power of growth spurts and plenty of physical activity.

As I’ve gotten older—as my tastes have changed and my expectations of food have changed—I’ve learned to make salads that I truly do love. Here’s what I’ve learned.

1. Local lettuce has an amazingly tasty flavor and tender texture. Finding a farmer’s market (and I mean a weekly or monthly fair where local farmers drive in to sell their goods, not just a store that happens to have put “farmer’s market” in its name) can be a boon to your tastebuds, fill your body with good nutrients, and help shrink your waistline, because local foods are so much fresher. They have a higher vitamin count than non-local foods, and they taste better with less adornment than ones that have been shipped thousands of miles.

2. In the winter, if local lettuce isn’t available, there are plenty of tasty salad alternatives from winter greens (such as kale and chard), winter fruits (such as citrus), and winter vegetables (roasted butternut, onions, turnips, etc.).

3. If I just have to have a lettuce salad when I can’t get lettuce from my local farmers, if I absolutely must buy some at Whole Foods instead, iceberg is not the way to go. In general, iceberg is rarely the basis of a tasty salad (except perhaps a wedge salad, but that harkens back to ye old drench-the-greens-in-fat childhood meals). Spring lettuce, romaine lettuce, herb salad mix—these are tasty bases for a green salad. Iceberg is not. (And for your own health alone, buying organic really matters here, too; you’re either eating leaves that were drenched in poison or leaves that only came in contact with dirt. Go for the dirt-only organics.)

4. Some people will suggest that if you are watching your waistline, you should only top your salad with low-calorie toppings and dressings. I completely disagree. Now, low-calorie toppings can be really, incredibly excellent on a salad; they can even make a salad. I have thought before how perfectly some shredded carrots complemented the other ingredients in a salad I was eating. But a good salad is about balance and contrast—the sweet contrasting with the tangy contrasting with the salty, the rough contrasting with the smooth. Etc. You want to fall in love with eating salads, not force yourself to struggle through each one. You want to think, “What would make a good dinner tonight? Oooh, I want a _____ salad.” It’s hard to get that appealing balance of tastes and textures if you only use low-calorie toppings—for example, crunchy and mild, crunchy and mild, and crunchy and mild–topped with astringent pure vinegar, too. On the other hand, it’s also hard to get that balance if you top your salad with greasy fat, greasy fat, and greasy fat. If you’re using good, high-quality ingredients in your salad (and you should be—this is all about taking care of yourself), you want to be able to taste those ingredients, so you don’t want to smother the salad in a pile of high-fat dressing. But a salad with some fat in the dressing tends to taste way better and have a better mouthfeel, and, as a bonus, those of us with sensitive tummies can use a little alkalinity from oil to balance out the acid in the dressing. Personally, I prefer a ratio of 2 or 3 to 1 ratio when it comes to oil/vinegar (or other acid) in my salad dressings. And I prefer one or two higher-calorie toppings (nuts, strong cheese, seeds, dried fruit, gf croutons) combined with some lower-calorie, contrasting-flavor ones (onions, tomatoes, pickled beets) in each salad. Combinations like that keep me coming back for more.

5. When I say high-quality toppings, I mean use real ones. Local ones are going to taste better; organic ones are going to be better for you and better for the environment. Fry up a piece of bacon instead of using Bacos. (You can even fry it up and freeze it so you can take a single slice to crumble in your salad each day.) Make some homemade croutons (again, a freezer and toaster can simplify this process for quick meals). Buy real cheese from the cheese department, and grate it or cut it up yourself. (It just tastes better.) Strongly flavored cheese–like blue cheese, feta, and sharp cheddar—can provide lots of flavor even when you use less of it than you usually would. Creamy cheeses like goat cheese can provide a heavenly contrast. Make yourself an easy, homemade dressing in an old, washed jelly jar with a lid; shake it well, put it in the fridge, and use it up bit by bit over a week or two. (Have you ever looked at the ingredients in store-bought dressings? It’s horrifying how much fake stuff they can pack in lots of those.) If I absolutely can’t manage the time to make a homemade dressing (and we all have those times), I use a store-bought dressing with only real ingredients in it—nothing I don’t recognize and nothing with ‘partially hydrogenated’ anything in it, since I ate a load of trans fats growing up and I know that they could kill me.

Here are a couple of my favorite salad meals/sides and easy homemade dressings that my husband and I have come to adore.


Apple-Poppy Salad
Can also be pear-poppy salad, peach-poppy salad, or others depending on the season

This salad combines salty, sweet, sour, crunchy, and chewy together. We usually use this as a filling, satisfying side dish for quick meals.

Per person
1 apple–sour or sweet depending on personal preference
2 t. sweet dried fruit (dried cherries, raisins, craisins, etc.)
1 T. pecan pieces or walnut pieces (we prefer salted for this salad)
2 t. poppyseed dressing

Make homemade poppyseed dressing, or use a good store-bought brand. (I love poppyseed dressing because it tastes creamy but involves none of that dairy that I can’t have.) Chop the apple into bite-size chunks. (Leave the skin on for extra fiber, or cut it off depending on your personal preference.) Put a small skillet on the stove and turn it on to medium heat. When the pan is hot, add the nuts. Toast them for 3-5 minutes, tossing them a couple of times, until their color begins to darken. Toss the apple, dried fruit, pecans, and poppyseed dressing together.


Greek Salad
When we make this salad, we use whichever of the appropriate toppings we happen to have in the fridge at the time. I keep our fridge stocked with kalamata olives in brine and sundried tomatoes in oil just for this type of thing. You can also make this more of an Italian salad if you switch up some of your ingredients.

Per person
1-2 c. salad greens, torn into bite-size pieces
4 kalamata olives or other preferred olive, sliced in halves or pieces
1 carrot, shredded on a box grater
1 tomato or 2 tsp. sundried tomato pieces
1/8 of a red onion, sliced down the middle and then sliced into very thin half-moons
1/2 cucumber, seeded if desired, sliced into chunky half-moons
1-2 oz. feta–in chunks or bite-size blocks
1 T. herb vinaigrette dressing (see recipe below)

Make dressing. Prep vegetables. Toss salad together or layer salad, depending on desired presentation. Sprinkle dressing on salad.

Herb Vinaigrette

1 T. balsamic vinegar (preferably a kind that’s been aged 10 years–it’s far superior)
2-3 T. olive oil
1 t. dried or 1 T. fresh, chopped herbs (for the Greek dressing, I make sure to include fresh oregano from my container garden)

Combine ingredients in a small, clean jar with a lid. Shake well. Serve or refrigerate. Lasts 1-2 weeks in fridge.

Lemon-Herb Dressing
A no-vinegar, reduced-acid dressing

juice of 1 lemon or Meyer lemon
3 T. olive oil
1 tsp. honey
1/2 tsp. seasoning salt
1 tsp. dried Italian herbs or 1 T. fresh chopped Italian herbs (I usually either throw in some chopped herbs from my container garden or use Mrs. Dash garlic and herbs seasoning)

Combine ingredients in a small jar with a lid. Put the lid on the jar, and shake well. Serve or refrigerate. Shake well before serving each time. Lasts about 1 week in fridge.

(For a lower-fat, high-taste creamy blue cheese dressing, see this post. Unfortunately for me, that delicious dressing does contain cow dairy.)

Tags: 2/3 veggies · allergen-free recipes · quick meals · vegetarian

18 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Helen // Feb 13, 2008 at 11:09 am

    I am totally with you on all this…we eat salads at least once a week for dinner (often more) and it’s pretty much always the same ingredients (organice herb mix or arugula, tomatoes, cucumber, celery, mushrooms, red onion and a protein with low-fat Trader Joes ranch dressing). What can I say? We love our yummy ruts. 😉 Thanks for the dressing recipes…I’m especially excited to try the blue cheese one! Yes, I like those white dressings a lot… 😉

  • 2 Meg Wolff // Feb 13, 2008 at 11:29 am

    Apples and nuts are a great combination … I need to make a salad!

    Love the photo your husband took of your eyes in your last blog post.

  • 3 Sarah // Feb 13, 2008 at 12:08 pm

    What a great post! I have realized how amazing local winter greens are (thanks to my CSA). I have made some amazing salads over the past few months and I am excited I have some fresh greens at home to make a couple of more. I agree that low fat dressings always aren’t the best option. While there are some good ones out there (to buy or make), fuller fat dressings can be used in moderations. I love the fact that there are multiple ways to dress a salad.

    (I was a child of the very same salads you spoke of, thank goodness I saw the light!)

  • 4 Beth // Feb 13, 2008 at 12:42 pm

    Wow, thanks! A great post. I have recently been eating more salads, in fact the last two days I have had romaine lettuce with chopped carrots, turkey chunks, raisins and dried cherries, and almonds, topped with a little salt, pepper, and basalmic vinegar. I really wanted to some creamy mild goat cheese to go with it. Your post has inspired me to play more with dressings, and reminded me how tasty fresh fruit is in salads.

    I love summer when there are fresh berries to be had on salads. There was one that I used to make with a sweet and sour poppy seed dressing and strawberries. Perhaps I will look for that recipe!

    Thanks for a great post filled with inspiration!

  • 5 Nikki // Feb 13, 2008 at 1:12 pm

    I have a salad for lunch every day, which is 2/3 salad, 1/3 cucumbers, peppers, grapes, sunflower sprouts, mushrooms, or whatever else we have that is a vegetable that will go in a salad, with a dash of cheese and some salad dressing made out of real food. It’s to the point now where I just can’t imagine a day without it. I don’t feel as well when I don’t eat a salad every day.

    Of course, this coming from the person who had 1/2 a chicken breast and a pile of zuchinni and broccolini when we got back from our trip. I missed veggies while in New Jersey.

  • 6 Cherie // Feb 13, 2008 at 2:23 pm

    A Greek salad sounds good – I can’t wait until the summer again when tomatoes are in season! I agree with you on the fat necessary for dressings. I’ve been making one with several different oils lately and feel great: coconut oil, flax oil, hempseed butter, extra-virgin olive oil.

  • 7 michelle // Feb 13, 2008 at 4:20 pm

    Each of these salads sound delicious! LB and I actually used to have one night a week designated as a night to try a new salad – I think it’s time to bring that tradition back because there are so many good ones out there! I like Cherie’s idea of using all those different oils too…

  • 8 justoofat // Feb 13, 2008 at 5:46 pm

    The apple poppy salad looks heavenly. I will definitely have to add this to my repertoire. Thanks for sharing your wonderful salad tips!


  • 9 glutenfreeforgood // Feb 13, 2008 at 8:16 pm

    Aaah, Meyer lemons are the best! Your lemon-herb dressing sounds wonderful. I lifted that off your post immediately! Thank you…

    I made a huge salad at lunch today and used some dried figs, a Bosc pear, jicama, carrots, pumpkin seeds — among other random things I had on hand. Oh, and yes, spinach and lettuce. There’s no limit to what you can use on a salad.

    Take care,

  • 10 Ricki // Feb 13, 2008 at 9:22 pm

    Mmmn. That apple-poppy salad sounds divine!

  • 11 Jenn // Feb 13, 2008 at 9:28 pm

    Sounds delicious. I am really loving to learn salads, too, and to experiment more. Thanks for giving me more ideas!

  • 12 Nikki // Feb 14, 2008 at 10:05 am

    YUMMMM. I am going to try the apple-poppy seed salad really soon. I have apples at home to be used, too!

    I’m very into salads as well. My latest fave has been spring mix/gorgonzola/walnuts/tomato/neumann’s raspberry vinagrette. YUM.

  • 13 Laura N // Feb 14, 2008 at 11:54 am

    Thank you for your encouragement today on my blog. I really appreciate it. And needed it, too!

    Best of luck with all your life changes/peripheral struggles going on right now. You’ve got your hands full, but at least you’ve got a base of self reliance and healthy living built up. AND you LOOK fabulous, which always helps. =)

  • 14 Christy // Feb 14, 2008 at 2:48 pm

    Now I want to run out and get tons of fresh veggies and goat cheese to make a yummy salad!!!

  • 15 Patricia Scarpin // Feb 15, 2008 at 9:37 am

    Sally, I liked your post so much! Salads can be interesting without having to be drenched in calories. I love adding cheese and fruit to my salads and these suggestions of yours are delicious!

  • 16 Roxie // Feb 15, 2008 at 10:37 am

    Great post! I was having similar thoughts just this week about how my tastes had changed over the years, especially salad. Thanks for the inspiration; I think I’ll make the apple poppyseed salad tonight. As always, I enjoy your posts.

  • 17 Travel Food (Managing Food Restrictions on Trips) // Oct 20, 2008 at 5:22 pm

    […] can, of course, make a million variations on salads—but be aware that many pre-made, packaged salads-to-go in grocery stores have weird […]

  • 18 SmarterFitter Blog » Blog Archive » Food Diary: Of Salads and Vinaigrette // Nov 12, 2008 at 2:03 pm

    […] get those HEALTHY fats we’re all desperate to get our chops on. Sally has an awesome post on learning to love salads in which she writes about the importance of fat in dressing, not only for flavor, but for healthy […]

Leave a Comment

Powered by WP Hashcash